Singing Loudly: International Law Compare and Contrast

Singing Loudly

Thursday, March 03, 2005

International Law Compare and Contrast

Will Baude has a good piece up at TNR where he essentially argues that the use of international law in US legal decisions would be alright if it was done properly.

I argue that it was done fairly well by Kennedy. I would ask Mr. Baude how soon he thinks the US legal system can actually incorporate the complex and growing girth of international law into our system? We've ignored it, disparged it, and acted like isn't important for so long that there is a very, very, very small minority of legal practitioners and scholars who understand international law. I would guess that nobody on the Supreme Court would be considered even marginally adept with international law. They might have a little knowledge of it. I would guess their clerks are not much better off.

The embarrassing aspect of international law is that a student who takes a public international law course and human rights course (or maybe a comparative law class) will have more knowledge about international law than the vast majority of practitioners and certainly more than almost every Judge on the federal bench.

It's a sad statement to our legal system that we have ignored it this long. Whether Kennedy's use of international law was perfect is not the reason I applaud him. I applaud him for his courage to use international law. It's not the first time the Supreme Court has done it but it's certainly too inconsistent to sit well with anyone who is looking at the landscape of our global legal system.


Do you really think the Constitution prevents the Court from doing anything at all?

And what on earth does the execution of 17 year olds have to do with our "global legal system"? It's barely even a national issue. It's certainly not an international one.

By Blogger Dylan, at 3:04 PM, March 03, 2005  

What does the execution of 17 year olds have to do with the global legal system? Obviously quite a bit but most importantly our treatment of foreign nationals and extradition of US nationals back to America. Some people would hope that we don't execute foreign nationals, but there are many who are executed. Whether or not any juveniles who are foreign nationals have been up for the DP is a question I can't answer.

By Blogger Curtis, at 7:17 PM, March 03, 2005  

Post a Comment

the archives:

You are currently viewing a post in the archives. You can go back to the main page, the topical index or continue perusing the archives below:

Posts by month:
Get awesome blog templates like this one from